Somewhere in my recent web travels (I coulda sworn it was someone on my friends list, but I can't find the post there now), I came across the following statement re the late Grand Master science-fiction author Robert A. Heinlein: "Heinlein couldn't write women if his life depended on it." A cursory Googling of the word pair "Heinlein women" turns up a whole raft of interesting posts, from both genders and on both sides of the question.
Apropos of the most recent posting on the gender gap, and since RAH happens to be one of my top three favorite SF authors (the late Isaac Asimov and the thankfully-not-late Spider Robinson being the others), I thought I'd throw this one out and see if it gets any more responses than the last one. Do you think Admiral Bob was capable of writing believable females, or not? Which author not of your own gender do you feel most gets your side right? Which one of your gender do you feel does right by the other one? And can we even discuss this without (a) getting hopelessly entangled in PC angst, (b) killing each other or (c) dragging in LeGuin's Left Hand of Darkness or some other gender-skirting work?
Apropos of the most recent posting on the gender gap, and since RAH happens to be one of my top three favorite SF authors (the late Isaac Asimov and the thankfully-not-late Spider Robinson being the others), I thought I'd throw this one out and see if it gets any more responses than the last one. Do you think Admiral Bob was capable of writing believable females, or not? Which author not of your own gender do you feel most gets your side right? Which one of your gender do you feel does right by the other one? And can we even discuss this without (a) getting hopelessly entangled in PC angst, (b) killing each other or (c) dragging in LeGuin's Left Hand of Darkness or some other gender-skirting work?