I had never even heard of Dr. George Tiller before last weekend. To a great many women in dire need of an abortion, he was a life-saver...in some cases, quite literally. And in the eyes of a greater many on the self-styled "pro-life" side of the national debate on reproductive health, he was a despicable killer of unborn children.
Yesterday, one of those in that last group decided that since the government would not stop Dr. Tiller from doing this work, he would take it upon himself to do so. This alleged human shot Dr. Tiller dead in the vestibule of the Lutheran church in Wichita, KS where he was serving as an usher. The surpassing irony of taking an innocent life in the name of saving other innocents, or of profaning the very house of the God to whom this killer and his ilk profess fealty, is doubtless utterly lost on him, as is the idea that the Fifth Commandment (or Sixth, depending on which church you grew up in)—"Thou shalt not kill"—might apply equally to both himself and the good doctor. Tiller had already been shot once previously and his clinic bombed, and he was a frequent target of threats and harassment from the anti side; Wikipedia's page on him lists some of the history. What made Dr. Tiller especially controversial was his willingness to perform so-called "late-term" abortions (or as the antis prefer to call them, "partial-birth" abortions), i.e., after the 21st week of pregnancy, well beyond the cutoff point of most US and Canadian abortion providers.
Police have today released the name of the suspect apprehended yesterday: one Scott Roeder, 51, of the nearby town of Merriam, who is alleged to have been a subscriber to a militant anti-abortion newsletter and a member of a radical militia group. The New York Times reports more here. Naturally, Your Humble Correspondent will not speculate on whether Roeder is in fact the gunman, as that is more properly the purview of the judge and jury which shall shortly be empaneled to consider the case. Anti-abortion groups including the National Right to Life Committee and Randall Terry's Operation Rescue, to their credit, have promptly and forcefully denounced the murder, insisting that they only practice and condone peaceful protest and political activism; how often they themselves have honored this proclaimed tenet more in the breach than the observance is left as a research exercise for the reader. This may be sincere expression of horror, or simple political savvy on their part in not letting themselves be tarred with the brush of extremism charges in a time when the pendulum of public opinion is swinging away from them; I leave it to you to judge which.
My heart goes out to Dr. Tiller's widow Jeanne, their children and grandchildren, and Dr. Tiller's staff, friends and colleagues. He becomes the eighth abortion-services worker, and the fourth doctor, in North America to be slaughtered for doing his job. May justice come to his murderer swiftly and harshly...and may this cause all of us on both sides to be more respectful of opponents' views and cautious about our use of incendiary rhetoric (most certainly not excluding myself).
Yesterday, one of those in that last group decided that since the government would not stop Dr. Tiller from doing this work, he would take it upon himself to do so. This alleged human shot Dr. Tiller dead in the vestibule of the Lutheran church in Wichita, KS where he was serving as an usher. The surpassing irony of taking an innocent life in the name of saving other innocents, or of profaning the very house of the God to whom this killer and his ilk profess fealty, is doubtless utterly lost on him, as is the idea that the Fifth Commandment (or Sixth, depending on which church you grew up in)—"Thou shalt not kill"—might apply equally to both himself and the good doctor. Tiller had already been shot once previously and his clinic bombed, and he was a frequent target of threats and harassment from the anti side; Wikipedia's page on him lists some of the history. What made Dr. Tiller especially controversial was his willingness to perform so-called "late-term" abortions (or as the antis prefer to call them, "partial-birth" abortions), i.e., after the 21st week of pregnancy, well beyond the cutoff point of most US and Canadian abortion providers.
Police have today released the name of the suspect apprehended yesterday: one Scott Roeder, 51, of the nearby town of Merriam, who is alleged to have been a subscriber to a militant anti-abortion newsletter and a member of a radical militia group. The New York Times reports more here. Naturally, Your Humble Correspondent will not speculate on whether Roeder is in fact the gunman, as that is more properly the purview of the judge and jury which shall shortly be empaneled to consider the case. Anti-abortion groups including the National Right to Life Committee and Randall Terry's Operation Rescue, to their credit, have promptly and forcefully denounced the murder, insisting that they only practice and condone peaceful protest and political activism; how often they themselves have honored this proclaimed tenet more in the breach than the observance is left as a research exercise for the reader. This may be sincere expression of horror, or simple political savvy on their part in not letting themselves be tarred with the brush of extremism charges in a time when the pendulum of public opinion is swinging away from them; I leave it to you to judge which.
My heart goes out to Dr. Tiller's widow Jeanne, their children and grandchildren, and Dr. Tiller's staff, friends and colleagues. He becomes the eighth abortion-services worker, and the fourth doctor, in North America to be slaughtered for doing his job. May justice come to his murderer swiftly and harshly...and may this cause all of us on both sides to be more respectful of opponents' views and cautious about our use of incendiary rhetoric (most certainly not excluding myself).