This editorial in yesterday's New York Times calls it exactly right. Tomorrow morning, a bunch of conservative ministers and priests across the US plan to defy a 54-year-old federal law that says churches endorsing or opposing particular political candidates, parties, ballot propositions or legislation cannot do so and demand exemption from taxes at the same time. Claiming their First Amendment rights are being infringed, they're staging a mass action and calling it "Pulpit Freedom Sunday." (Give you three guesses which Presidential candidate they'll support, and the first two don't count.)
Even leaving aside my well-known bias against organized religion, the rule makes perfect sense to me. If you want a say in public policy and how government monies are spent, you put some skin in the game. If you're not willing to help pay the cost of government, you can't be held accountable to anyone for the influence you have over who gets elected and what laws get passed.
And it's not as if the clergy aren't already free to express opinions on political matters. They just can't do so in their official capacity as leaders of a congregation, synagogue, mosque or parish, from the pulpit, and still get off not paying taxes. Besides, the ReligiousRight Wrong already has had far too much access to churches as a political organizing tool as it is, thanks to the late, unlamented (by some of us, anyway) Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority and its successor groups like Focus on the Family. They've been passing out voter guides in church parking lots and using mailing lists provided by sympathizers inside for at least two decades now. "Wall of separation"? Who dat?
They're hoping to get their day in court—the Supreme Court, where they evidently think the current conservative-larded bench will side with them and throw out the law. If there is a God, may She grant my prayer that these cassocked yahoos and their right-wing backers are wrong.
Even leaving aside my well-known bias against organized religion, the rule makes perfect sense to me. If you want a say in public policy and how government monies are spent, you put some skin in the game. If you're not willing to help pay the cost of government, you can't be held accountable to anyone for the influence you have over who gets elected and what laws get passed.
And it's not as if the clergy aren't already free to express opinions on political matters. They just can't do so in their official capacity as leaders of a congregation, synagogue, mosque or parish, from the pulpit, and still get off not paying taxes. Besides, the Religious
They're hoping to get their day in court—the Supreme Court, where they evidently think the current conservative-larded bench will side with them and throw out the law. If there is a God, may She grant my prayer that these cassocked yahoos and their right-wing backers are wrong.